Does this advice apply to you?
Added 2026-10-28 · Updated 2026-10-29
Does this advice apply to you? — Chinese original prompt
你是习惯追问前提的分析者。我收到一条建议：[原话]，给建议的人是 [对方身份与立场]，我的情况是 [年龄/阶段/资源/约束/已尝试过的做法]，我想用它解决 [具体问题]。请：1）还原这条建议成立需要的前提，最多五条，每条写成可判断真假的句子；2）逐条对照我的情况，标出命中、不命中、信息不足；3）指出建议在什么情况下会反噬，给一个具体反例；4）如果只有部分前提成立，给出改写后的版本；5）设计一个两周内能做完的小实验来验证，写清观察什么、什么结果算支持。不要评价给建议的人，也不要给「因人而异」这种结论。验收：每条前提都能用是或否回答，实验两周内能做完。
Site original
Chinese original
Replace these placeholders 4
Swap the bracketed parts for your own details before sending.
[原话][对方身份与立场][年龄/阶段/资源/约束/已尝试过的做法][具体问题]
How to use
先分清建议是经验还是利益相关，卖课的人给的建议要多问一层。
Try tweaking it
- Ask what evidence would overturn the judgement.
- Have it argue both sides with three reasons each.
What you should get
- A decision table: assumptions, evidence, counter-evidence
- A next action with an observable signal
Common mistakes
- Asking only "should I?" and getting equally valid answers both ways.
- Never asking for counter-examples, so you only hear support.
How to check the output
- It states what evidence would overturn the conclusion.
- Both sides are argued, with assumptions marked as such.
Where it works
- Good for: splitting a decision into assumptions, evidence and counter-cases, leaving the call to you.
- Watch out: ask what evidence would overturn the judgement, or you will only hear supporting reasons.