Code Review That Asks Why
Added 2026-10
Code Review That Asks Why — Chinese original prompt
这是我的[语言]代码：[粘贴代码]，场景是[用途]，我担心[性能/可读性/边界]。请以评审者身份只提问不直接改：问这段为什么这样组织、异常路径怎么处理、如果[输入变化]会怎样、有没有更简单的写法。每个问题后面等我回答，再决定是否给建议。
Site original
Chinese original
Example
Sample input
这是我的 Python 代码，用在批量导入订单，我担心边界输入会出问题。
The output should include
- 只提问题而不直接改动代码
- 追问异常路径和输入变化情况
- 等我回答再决定是否给建议
Replace these placeholders 5
Swap the bracketed parts for your own details before sending.
[语言][粘贴代码][用途][性能/可读性/边界][输入变化]
How to use
先答完问题再让它改，直接改会让你学不到东西。
Try tweaking it
- Set a turn limit (e.g. 5) and an exit condition, then ask for a score and rewrites.
- Have it play only the counterpart: no advice, no acting on your behalf.
What you should get
- A full exchange where the AI stays in the counterpart role
- A score plus sentences you could reuse
Common mistakes
- No turn limit, so the AI plays on and you never practise closing.
- Letting it both play the counterpart and coach you — the role blurs and nothing sticks.
How to check the output
- The AI plays only the counterpart — no advice, no acting for you.
- It ends with a score or rewritten lines that identify what worked.
Where it works
- Good for: having AI play only the counterpart, stay in role for a fixed number of turns, then step out and give a score or rewrite.
- Watch out: set the turn limit and exit condition; for medical or legal scenes, get professional review.